UK. Built from HMRC's recognised software list

Which is the best payroll software for a UK small business?

HMRC's free payroll software list has seven products, recognised for businesses with fewer than 10 employees.

Choosing or switching payroll software?

Next: where to reach you.

  • Free, no obligation
  • We take no commission from any supplier on this page
  • Your details go to at most three providers

Leave your email and we'll get straight back to you.

  1. We email you the questions a firm needs answered, straight away.
  2. You answer them by reply, or on this site.
  3. Up to three firms get your request.

10 compared, HMRC list

  1. Basic PAYE ToolsFree list, published by HMRC itself
  2. Collegia FreePayrollFree list, as Collegia Partners Ltd
  3. Employment Hero Free PayrollPaid-for list, as Employment Hero Payroll from Employment Hero (UK) Ltd (gov.uk, read 30 October 2026)
  4. Primo PayrollFree list, as Accentra Technologies Ltd
Cost
Runs
Option gov.uk, updated 16 October 2026, read 30 October 2026 supplier's own page, 15 Aug 2026
Basic PAYE Tools HMRC's own free tool, under 10 employeesFree list, published by HMRC itselfFreeFewer than 10 employees, stated by gov.ukNot mentioned on gov.uk, which describes tax, National Insurance and HMRC submissions onlySends payroll information to HMRC. gov.uk does not say it produces payslips, and says it is not designed for agents or bookkeepers
Collegia FreePayroll Free cloud payroll with a pension attachedFree list, as Collegia Partners LtdFree. Supplier states no credit card and no trial periodHMRC lists the free products for under 10 employees. The supplier states no employee limitYes. Auto-enrolment through Collegia's own pension, described as built inYes. Payslips, P45s and P60s, with FPS and EPS submitted to HMRC
Employment Hero Free Payroll Free cloud payroll without a headcount capPaid-for list, as Employment Hero Payroll from Employment Hero (UK) Ltd (gov.uk, read 30 October 2026). It was on the free list when read on 15 August 2026£0 a month, stated as free forever with no trial periodThe supplier states unlimited employees on its free product. HMRC no longer lists it on the free tableYes. Assess, enrol and re-enrol staff, with pension contributions submittedYes. Payslips generated and sent automatically, RTI auto-submitted to HMRC
Primo Payroll A free tier with paid support if you need itFree list, as Accentra Technologies LtdEssentials Free Plus at £0. Paid Essentials tiers at £24.99 and £49.99 a year, mainly buying support10 employees on the free tierYes. Described as a fully automated auto-enrolment solution with contributions calculated and processedYes. Payslips produced, with RTI submissions tracked in the system
Moneysoft Payroll Manager Fixed annual cost, CIS includedPaid-for list, as Moneysoft Limited£95 a year excluding VAT for Payroll Manager 20. £190 and £285 for the 100 and 250 versionsUp to 20 employees or subcontractors for one employer, leavers in the tax year includedYes. Assessment report, output files for major providers and a direct link to NESTYes, and CIS subcontractors are handled in the same product
Xero Payroll Payroll bolted onto bookkeeping you already doPaid-for list, as XeroPlans at £16, £37, £50 and £65 a month excluding VAT, with introductory rates for the first 6 monthsIgnite at £16 includes no payroll people and charges £1.50 per person. Grow at £37 includes one personYes. Automatic enrolment and re-enrolment, submitting contributions directly to Nest and The People's PensionYes, through the Xero Me app or email. RTI filed after every pay run
FreeAgent Free with a NatWest, RBS, Ulster or Mettle accountPaid-for list, as FreeAgent Central Ltd£19 a month for sole traders, £27 for partnerships, £33 for limited companies, with introductory rates. Free while you hold a qualifying NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland, Ulster Bank or Mettle accountNo per-employee charge: add as many employees as you need at no extra costPartial. It calculates pension contributions from default settings. The payroll page does not describe auto-enrolment assessment or submissions to a pension providerYes. Payslips and P60s generated, RTI submitted directly to HMRC
IRIS Staffology Payroll Growing headcount priced per payslipPaid-for list, as IRIS (Staffology)£43 a month for 19 payslips or fewer, plus £2.15 per payslip from 20 to 50. Above 51, quote only. All prices subject to VAT19 payslips a month on the flat feeNot described on the product page we checkedYes, through an e-payslips portal with P60s. Priced by the number of RTI submissions in the billing period
BrightPay Widely used by UK bureaux and their clientsPaid-for list, as Bright Software Group LtdNot published. The pricing page offers annual and monthly plans and sends you to an on-site quote calculatorNot published. Above 250 employees for a single employer is quote onlyYes. Auto-enrolment tasks automated, with contribution submissions to providers including NEST, The People's Pension and Smart PensionYes, including an employee self-service portal. The site describes itself as RTI and HMRC recognised
PayFit UK Payroll and HR together, sales-ledPaid-for list, as PayFit LtdNot published. The site has no pricing page: it routes you to a demo bookingNot published. The site segments by under 25 employees and 25 or moreYes. Pension submissions sent automatically alongside RTI, and auto-enrolment listed among the tasks it automatesYes. Payslips sent and stored automatically, RTI submissions sent automatically to HMRC

Every free payroll product on HMRC's recognised list, and what its supplier actually says

Last updated

HMRC's list names seven free payroll products and states they are recognised for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. It does not say what each one includes. This table follows the link gov.uk publishes for each supplier and records what we could read there.

Column one and two are copied verbatim from the free payroll software table on gov.uk's 'Find payroll software that is recognised by HMRC' page, last updated 16 October 2026 and read again on 30 October 2026, which states that this free software is recognised by HMRC for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. Column three records only what we could read on the supplier's own page on 15 August 2026, reached through the link gov.uk publishes for that supplier. Where a supplier's page stated no price or no limit, the row says so rather than filling the gap. HMRC states it cannot recommend one product over another, and neither do we: nothing in this table is a rating.

Every free payroll product on HMRC's recognised list, and what its supplier actually says
ProductSupplier, in HMRC's wordingWhat the supplier's own page said, 15 August 2026
Basic PAYE ToolsHMRCFree download for Windows, macOS and Linux. gov.uk states it is for businesses with fewer than 10 employees, that it performs most payroll tasks, and that it is not designed for agents or bookkeepers.
Collegia FreePayrollCollegia Partners LtdFree, with the supplier stating no employee limit. Payslips, P45s, P60s, FPS and EPS, with Collegia auto-enrolment pension built in.
Primo PayrollAccentra Technologies LtdEssentials Free Plus tier at £0 for 10 employees. Paid Essentials tiers at £24.99 and £49.99 a year add email and phone support.
Enrolpay - Small PayrollEnrolpay LtdDescribed on the supplier's site as free payroll software for companies with less than 10 employees, with employee access to payslips, holidays and pension documents.
RTI LiteHartigan Software Design LtdA Windows desktop submission tool rather than a full payroll: free for 1 to 9 employees, £121 a year excluding VAT for 10 to 16. It takes data from an existing payroll package or an Excel template and sends FPS and EPS.
1 A Simple PayrollIT Contractors LtdPrice shown as free. Cloud platform for RTI e-filing and payslips, with tips and tronc calculation as its focus.
Stansoft LinuxStansoftAccounting and payroll software for the Linux platform, covering UK PAYE RTI. The supplier's own page describes it as suited to people comfortable with the command line.
  • HMRC's list of recognised payroll software names seven free products and states they are recognised for businesses with fewer than 10 employees (gov.uk, last updated 16 October 2026, read 30 October 2026).
  • HMRC publishes its own free payroll software, Basic PAYE Tools, as a download for Windows, macOS and Linux, for businesses with fewer than 10 employees.
  • Recognition means the software can be used to report PAYE to HMRC online. gov.uk states plainly that HMRC cannot recommend one product or service over another.
  • Of the ten products compared here, two publish no price at all: BrightPay quotes through an on-site calculator and PayFit through a demo booking (checked 15 August 2026).
  • One of the free-list entries is narrower than it looks: RTI Lite is a submission tool that takes data from an existing payroll package.

Cite this page

“Every free payroll product on HMRC's recognised list, and what its supplier actually says”, Payroll Software Compare, https://payrollsoftwarecompare.co.uk/ (updated 2026-08-15). Column one and two are copied verbatim from the free payroll software table on gov.uk's 'Find payroll software that is recognised by HMRC' page, last updated 16 October 2026 and read again on 30 October 2026, which states that this free software is recognised by HMRC for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. Column three records only what we could read on the supplier's own page on 15 August 2026, reached through the link gov.uk publishes for that supplier. Where a supplier's page stated no price or no limit, the row says so rather than filling the gap. HMRC states it cannot recommend one product over another, and neither do we: nothing in this table is a rating.

How we chose and ordered these

  • Options: small and medium UK employer products on HMRC's recognised list (updated 16 October 2026, read 30 October 2026), sites read 15 August 2026. Free first, then cheapest published, then 'quote only'. Prices are copied, never estimated. No scores, tests, reviews or ranking. Sage and QuickBooks refused our checks. Of 150+ paid-for products, absence means uncovered, not unsuitable. No commission.

Payroll Software Compare is an information site. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or connected to HMRC or any software supplier named here, and nothing on it is tax, accounting or legal advice. We take no commission from any supplier in this comparison and carry no paid placements. Supplier prices and features change without notice: every figure carries the date we read it on the supplier's own page, and you should confirm the current position there before buying.

Common questions

Does payroll software have to be HMRC-recognised?

No rule names a particular product. The duty is to report your employees' pay and deductions to HMRC on or before their payday. HMRC lists the software it recognises for reporting PAYE online; choosing from it is the simplest way to be confident a submission is accepted. HMRC states it cannot recommend one product or service over another.

Is there free payroll software that HMRC recognises?

Yes. Gov.uk's recognised software page has a free table of seven products, recognised by HMRC for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. HMRC's own Basic PAYE Tools is one, a free download for Windows, macOS and Linux. The list was last updated on 16 October 2026 and read here on 30 October 2026.

Is HMRC's Basic PAYE Tools enough to run a small payroll?

Gov.uk says it performs most payroll tasks, including working out tax and National Insurance and sending it to HMRC, for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. It has some limitations and is not designed for agents or bookkeepers. The page does not describe payslips or pension auto-enrolment, so check those against your duties before relying on it alone.

Which payroll software handles pension auto-enrolment?

Auto-enrolment is separate from PAYE; HMRC recognition says nothing about it. Collegia FreePayroll, Employment Hero Free Payroll, Primo Payroll, Moneysoft Payroll Manager, Xero Payroll, BrightPay and PayFit describe assessment or contribution submissions. FreeAgent's page describes pension contributions, not auto-enrolment. The IRIS Staffology Payroll page we checked does not mention it. Check the supplier's current page first.

How much does UK payroll software cost?

Prices on 15 August 2026 ran from £0 to £43 a month plus VAT. Moneysoft Payroll Manager £95 a year excluding VAT, up to 20 employees; Xero from £16 a month excluding VAT plus £1.50 per payroll person. FreeAgent £19 to £33 a month; IRIS Staffology Payroll £43 a month plus VAT, up to 19 payslips. BrightPay and PayFit quote.

Why are Sage and QuickBooks not in the comparison?

Both are on HMRC's recognised list of payroll software. Neither website would answer our automated checks, so we could not read a current price or feature list. We do not publish a row we cannot verify. That is a limitation of this comparison, not a judgement on either product.

Can I switch payroll software part way through a tax year?

Yes, and it is common. Carry year-to-date figures across accurately for every employee and keep your PAYE reference and pension scheme details aligned. Make sure only one system files a Full Payment Submission for a given pay period. Before you commit, ask the supplier what its mid-year import needs from your current system.

Is Moneysoft's Payroll Manager software recognised by HMRC?

Yes. Moneysoft Limited's Payroll Manager is on the paid-for table of gov.uk's Find payroll software that is recognised by HMRC page (updated 16 October 2026, read 30 October 2026). On 15 August 2026, Payroll Manager 20 was £95 a year excluding VAT: one employer, up to 20 employees, leavers counted. Payroll Manager 100, £190, removes the employer limit.

Sources

This site's own datasets, every figure quoted from its source and dated:

  • The UK Payroll Software Price Index carries 12 published figures read from 8 sources' own pages; the 8 published figures given without a breakdown run from 1 to 46 GBP (11 sources publish a figure), read 11 November 2026.
  • The UK Payroll Statutory Rates carries 66 published figures read from 8 sources' own pages, from 5 to 3,000,000 GBP, read 11 November 2026.
  1. gov.uk, find payroll software that is recognised by HMRC (last updated 16 October 2026)
  2. gov.uk, download HMRC's Basic PAYE Tools
  3. gov.uk, payroll software
  4. gov.uk, running payroll: reporting to HMRC
  5. gov.uk, workplace pensions: joining a workplace pension
  6. The Pensions Regulator, employer duties

Start from the list, not the ads

Seven free products on HMRC's list, eight suppliers that publish what they charge and two that will not, each traceable to the page it came from.

Talk to a specialist